The P.U.S.H. Delusion
Tuesday, August 7th, 2007Pray: To ask that the laws of the universe be annulled in behalf of a single petitioner confessedly unworthy.
Ambrose Bierce, The Devil’s Dictionary
Several years back, in my hands I held a binder that belonged to a relative. The binder was covered with the phrase PUSH neatly scribbled in many sizes and styles. Had the acronym not been spelled out along side - Pray Until Something Happens -, I’d likely have forgotten the whole episode. Having recently seen the phrase again, armed with science, psychology and philosophy I dissect the phrase loved by so many Christians.
PUSH really brings out the benefits of religion, better than any other phrase I’m familiar with. First we have the psychological satisfaction and feeling of doing something about an issue, the psychological equivalent of crying1. Second, we have a powerful message that every church loves for their members to believe - “Only God has control, and we are your best conduit to Him.” Third is the absolution from negative consequences - “Blame yourself not, for if you prayed and things went bad, such was God’s will.” As with most of religion, that’s just all too convenient, isn’t it?
Christianity often sees science as the forbidden fruit, the tree of knowledge in the Garden of Eden who’s fruit we humans mustn’t taste. Christianity’s advice is not to understand and counter or encourage an effect, but to leave it all up to man upstairs - to resign yourself to the natural course, to PUSH. Indeed, so far as I can remember, there is not one word in the Gospels in praise of intelligence.2
Hypocrisy is one of the nicest labels I can apply to the practice. We all line up for the benefits of a pill that cures everything from a headache to an infection, the convenience of planes, trains and automobiles, the dentists that keep our teeth from rotting in our mouths, the blood transfusion after an accident or operation, the comfort of a phone call with mom, dad, child on another continent… yet some of us are pompous enough to walk around proclaiming PUSH?
I’ve yet to meet a Christian that chose to pray for a safe trip home in place of learning the rules of the road. You might choose to do both, but when it comes to life and death, prayer alone will seldom do, even for a fundamentalist. On the other hand, most individuals armed only with the rules of the road and logic get home just fine, and do so in exact same proportions as those that do pray ahead for a safe trip. Prayer has no effect on the external reality. Our actions are what brings by change.
PUSH is a cop out mentality. The only reason you and I can sit and discuss its values and the lack thereof is due to the many men and women whom accepted the burden of reality, as should we. If actions speak louder than words, no one really believes that prayer is a realistic solution to anything. That being the case, I urge all to stop perpetuating the myth.
NOTES
1 Crying is still a scientific mystery where theories abound and research is ongoing. The psychological release and feelings associated with it are but one proposition and factor of many on offer.
2 Bertrand Russel
